The Old Grog

Located in the heart of Menasha, Wisconsin, The Old Grog is a standout American restaurant and bar & grill that perfectly balances a laid-back, welcoming atmosphere with a menu packed full of hearty, flavorful classics. Whether you’re stopping by for a casual night with friends or a satisfying meal after a busy day, The Old Grog offers an authentic dining experience that truly hits the spot.

The cuisine here embraces quintessential American bar favorites with elevated touches that keep regulars coming back. The menu boasts a range of satisfying choices — from their legendary Bacon Cheeseburger and juicy Mushroom Swiss Burger smothered in rich brown gravy, to their crispy and comforting Fried Chicken Dinner. Not to be missed are the Perch Dinner, a Friday specialty featuring perfectly fried butterfly fillets paired with crisp coleslaw, and the hearty Hot Beef Sandwich that tastes like a warm, nostalgic hug.

Sandwich lovers will appreciate that all burgers are a generous half-pound of prime beef with customizable toppings such as raw or fried onions and pickles, and a gluten-free bun option available. The intriguing Stadium Burger — a combo of burger and bratwurst meat — delivers uniquely robust flavor that few places can match. For lighter fare or sharable bites, the Cheese Fries and Mango Habanero Wings bring both comfort and a touch of spice.

Midweek specials add a delicious twist to your dining calendar: think juicy Steak Sandwiches on Thursdays, savory Spaghetti and Meatballs with garlic bread on Wednesdays, and finger-licking boneless or traditional wings for just $6.50 on Tuesdays. These rotating deals deepen the menu’s appeal and showcase the kitchen’s consistent quality and friendly pricing.

The Old Grog’s bar is equally inviting, with a well-curated selection of beers, including the iconic Pabst Blue Ribbon, crisp ciders, and cocktails like expertly mixed old fashioneds. The relaxed, corner-bar vibe highlighted by reviewers creates an enjoyable space where locals and visitors alike feel right at home. As one guest shared, “The staff is always friendly and the food is consistent,” capturing the perfect blend of great service and an upbeat social atmosphere.

Multiple patrons rave about the unforgettable burger experience — from their generous portion sizes to the surprising excellence of the fries, which even non-fry fans admit are irresistible. Another reviewer called it a “fun, relaxed, corner bar kind of atmosphere” with great bartenders who elevate the dining outing to something memorable. Whether enjoying crispy, jumbo wings or sinking into a perfectly cooked steak sandwich with fries or onion rings, you can expect flavors that satisfy deeply and keep appetites coming back for more.

In all, The Old Grog offers more than just a meal; it’s a genuine neighborhood gem where comfort food is crafted with care, portions are hearty, and the ambiance invites you to kick back and savor the moment. If you haven’t tried their renowned burger lineup or their Friday fish fry, it’s time to make a date — your taste buds and wallet will thank you.